Feb.1 - Two prominent Formula 1 insiders have criticised the decision to slam the door shut to Andretti-Cadillac.

Although former McLaren driver Michael Andretti's US-based motor racing empire was welcomed by the governing FIA, commercial rights holder Liberty Media has finally now issued a resounding "No" - at least for now.

In a statement, F1 said an eleventh team would not "provide value" to the sport unless it is "competitive" - and that Andretti would, in contrast, add "operational burden" and costs to promoters whilst taking away resources from "other competitors".

However, although chiding team officials for turning down an invitation to London in December, Formula 1 gave hope to Andretti if GM or Cadillac follows through on the pledge to build a works engine for 2028.

In response, Andretti-Cadillac said it "strongly disagrees" with Formula One Management, having already put together a team of 120 staff and revealed a wind tunnel model.

Fernando Alonso & Mario Andretti

Fernando Alonso & Mario Andretti (2012)

Michael Andretti's famous father Mario posted on X: "I'm devastated. I won't say anything else because I can't find any other words besides devastated."

Some believe Liberty and the teams are only delaying Andretti's potential entry until 2028 because, by then, the 'new team' compensatory fee could have risen from its current $200 million to triple that amount.

Alexey Popov, a well-known Russian F1 commentator, criticised Formula 1 for slamming the door shut to a new entrant.

"The press release said that if they had a GM engine already, they'd be accepted," he said. "Well, sorry, but Brawn, Red Bull - did they immediately have their own engines?

"Imagine if Stewart had not been allowed to enter in 1997 - we wouldn't have Red Bull now. It didn't come out of nowhere," Popov said. "If BAR hadn't been allowed in, there wouldn't be a Mercedes now. If Jordan hadn't been allowed in, there wouldn't be an Aston Martin now.

"If this principle had always been followed, there'd be no teams in Formula 1 at all. They even would have managed to keep Ferrari out in the 50s.

"I was never a fan of Michael Andretti, but Mario Andretti is a legend who won everything. How can you now not let them in?" the Russian insisted.

With a similar view is Michael Schmidt, the top correspondent for Germany's specialist Auto Motor und Sport, who sensed "personal resentments" played a role in Andretti's rejection.

"I don't know if he understood what he was getting himself into," he said. "Maybe the Americans simply acted too boldly for everyone's liking, trying to force their way in.

"But by rejecting the application, Formula 1 has also slammed the door on itself," Schmidt added. "If the criteria mentioned (by F1) applies, then no other applicant can hope to be accepted into the premier class either."

As for F1's claim that Andretti-Cadillac would not have won races or podiums, he commented: "Not even the long-established teams can do that at the moment.

"They also say that a new manufacturer could take years to become successful - then this also applies to Audi and Ford," Schmidt explained.

"And if Formula 1 claims that the Andretti name adds no value, then it shouldn't have allowed team names like 'Stake F1' or 'Visa Cash App RB'. They certainly won't attract any new fans.

"And in the US growth market, Andretti is definitely different from the new tongue twisters."


✅ Check out more posts with related topics:

7 F1 Fan comments on “Mario Andretti Devastated as F1 Rejects Son's New Team

  1. shroppyfly

    As Toto put it, Its just about the money..., the fia cant demand a bigger fee than 200M Now because thats the rules, but come 2027/8 the entrance fee will be 700M so thats 70M for each team because theyll have changed the rules, i understand Andretti being upset but, im sure theyve worked into there programme this scenario, basically the Fia have cowered down to pressure from the teams about 200M not being enough

  2. Les

    Absolutely vested interests by current teams. They should not be allowed to have a say.
    Haas and Williams are not competitive, nonsense reasons for rejection. Lets hope Haas remains uncompetitive and Gene Haas decides to sell, that could be Andretti's way in. Andretti would do far better with that team than Gene Haas.

  3. Les

    F1 trying to increase interest in USA with more races there then reject a US entrant with a famous US racing name , that would attract more fans.
    F1 shooting themselves in the foot.

  4. Tim Holy

    I wonder if Penske wanted into F1??
    What would the decision be.
    Penske and Andretti are synonymous with
    American racing at its pinnacle.

  5. Tim Holt

    I wonder if Penske wanted into F1??
    What would the decision be.
    Penske and Andretti are synonymous with
    American racing at its pinnacle.


  6. ✅ Checkout the latest 50 F1 Fans comments.

Comments are closed.